Recent criticism of Rob Key and Brendon McCullum’s England regime from active players is, according to England and Wales Cricket Board chief executive Richard Gould, largely a reaction to being dropped.
Jonny Bairstow, Reece Topley and Liam Livingstone have all spoken publicly about their experiences with the national setup overseen by managing director Key and head coach McCullum. Livingstone described his time at last year’s Champions Trophy as “the worst experience I’ve had playing cricket,” and Topley said the Lancashire all-rounder’s comments were “a bit kind.” Bairstow said last week: “you need the care back in the game,” adding that “as soon as you are out of the system, you are out of the system.” Topley and Bairstow last played for England in 2024, while Livingstone’s most recent appearance was a year ago.
Gould said: “When players come out of the England fold, it’s difficult for them. It’s difficult for any player when they get dropped in any sport and they will not agree with the decision. I wouldn’t want them to agree with the decision. These are competitive men and women seeking to play at the highest standard for as long as they can.” He noted the scale of demand for places: “On the men’s side, we’ve got 28 centrally contracted players. With the women, we’ve got about 16 centrally contracted players, but there’s probably about 300 players who want to play for our England teams. We do have to focus our resources on those that are in the teams.”
An ECB review into the 4-1 Ashes defeat kept Key, McCullum and Test captain Ben Stokes in place despite criticism of the team’s preparation, selection and behaviour. McCullum is currently in New Zealand and will rejoin England ahead of their first Test of the summer against the Black Caps on June 4; Gould said he did not yet know McCullum’s exact return date.
Gould also dismissed the idea of trying to persuade counties to stop signing Australian players ahead of the 2027 Ashes, despite Stokes calling it “odd” to give opponents experience of English conditions. “It would be against the law to discriminate against any nationality in terms of playing cricket so, no, there are no policies in place,” Gould said.
ECB managing director Rob Andrew added that the number of overseas players is regularly debated: “The game constantly debates the number of overseas players, the number in the Blast, the number in the County Championship. It goes to the bigger value of the county game as well, in terms of helping grow the game. Rob Key might want all the Australians banned from playing, but I don’t. It’s not something that was discussed during the domestic review. The only thing that is discussed periodically is do we have the right number of overseas players playing in our competitions?”